I recently started experimenting with BandLab, a pretty cool combination cloud music editing platform and app. The idea is pretty cool: use your mobile device to start on a project, away (presumably) from your cushy office and laptop. Then, you can work more readily at your laptop, later.
The app includes collaborative tools, and the option to ‘fork’ someone else’s work (if they’ve made it available) in order to make it your own. I like the idea.
So, I downloaded the app, and I made an account.
This is a different kind of account. It’s an accounting of my first impressions.
Recording on my mobile device
Because the phone’s built-in mic seemed to pick up more of the sounds of my fingers on the keyboard than the actual piano, I bought a splitter and a patch cable to record directly from the piano’s headphone jack.
Initially, I planned to use one headphone jack for the phone, and the other for real headphones (because it’s valuable to hear what you are playing — at least at my level of incompetence).
It was an adventure. I plugged everything in, and it seemed to work, but something about the setup was sending phantom headset volume control signals to my phone. The phone volume wasn’t important, but the constant notification was overlapping other things on the screen.
Google research was no help. Different apps were suggested, and I installed and then uninstalled them. (Guess whether they were effective or not.)
So, in case anybody is curious, here is what I learned the hard way: using the splitter with a microphone plugged in but no headphones caused the weird signal. I guess I could have gone digging for my old jogging headphones, just to have something plugged in, but I didn’t feel like standing up.
So, I tried using BandLab’s live patch-through setting, to hear what I was playing. That drove me crazy because there was a minuscule between playing a note and hearing it and that drove me crazy.
Now I know, and I think that the next time I sit down to record, things will go more quickly. (Most of the time I had blocked out to try recording went into sorting out the cables.)
My first impression
So, what did I think?
I’ll save you long, wandering reflections on how bad my piano playing sounded when played back to me. Instead, I had two takeaway lessons from my first attempt to record something in more than one track:
- Playing with a metronome is going to be important if I want this to work. Sure, you can listen to what you’ve already recorded as you play, but I need to get my rhythm locked down better. I loved that BandLab broke things down into measures (you can see them at the top of the multi-track window), but that’ll only be helpful if I stick with them.
- I’m going to need to think more deliberately about the building blocks of a piece. That goes for ABAC type song structuring, but also for ‘what is this track for?’ kind of thinking. What I did was pretty basic: play a piece I know on piano, play it again with the ‘strings’ setting on the epiano, combine them in the app.
Where is all this going?
I don’t know. With all the other things I’m working on, I don’t know why I have this in my head. There is a ton for me still to learn, but I’ve really enjoyed my time at the piano, and this gives me a little something to work towards.
Will I post songs that I’ve written? I don’t know. I have ideas for things to write about, though no real lyrics, yet.
More likely is that I’ll post MP3s of ‘orchestrations’ I’ve made for existing songs, or instrumental music that I’ve put together on several tracks.
Only time will tell.